Menopause care comparison

Stay Prime Health vs Alloy

Both are cash-pay, both charge a $49 first visit, and both publish their prices. Alloy has no membership and low listed hormone prices. Stay Prime is one monthly membership, and if your clinician decides a prescription is not right for you, that membership never starts.

Competitor prices checked November 2026; they may have changed.

The short version

Alloy may suit you if

  • You want a low listed price for an estradiol pill and progesterone, and you are happy paying per medication.3
  • You would rather not have a monthly membership at all.2
  • You want a wide choice of hormone forms, including pill, gel, spray, patch and vaginal cream.3

Stay Prime may suit you if

  • You want one monthly price for your care, with every cost shown before you pay.
  • You want your first visit fee back as a credit if you join.
  • You want no membership charge at all if a prescription is not right for you.

Side by side

Stay Prime Health and Alloy menopause care comparedCompetitor prices checked November 2026; they may have changed. Numbers link to sources below.
What you are comparingStay Prime HealthAlloy
First visit$49 one time. Credited to your first month if you join.$49 one time. Charged even if you do not go ahead with treatment.1
MembershipHer Balance, $89/mo. It starts only if your clinician prescribes.None for menopause care. You pay for each medication.2
Hormone medicationOnly if prescribed. You see the price before you approve anything.Estradiol pill from $39.99/mo, gel $69.99/mo, patch $100/mo, progesterone from $23/mo.3
Example: estradiol pill plus progesteroneHer Balance at $89/mo. Any medication cost is shown before you approve it.About $63/mo, adding Alloy’s listed starting prices for the two medications.3
If no prescriptionYour membership never starts. The visit fee covers your clinician’s time.The $49 consultation is kept.1
InsuranceNo insurance needed. You may be able to pay with an HSA or FSA card. We give you an itemized receipt to submit yourself.Cash-pay. HSA and FSA accepted.4
Where care is offeredthe states where our medical partner's clinicians are licensed (your state is confirmed before you pay)All 50 states and DC.4
ShippingShips in plain packaging.Free, discreet delivery.5

Where Alloy is strong

Alloy’s listed medication prices are low. An estradiol pill starts at $39.99 a month and progesterone at $23 a month, so a common pill-plus-progesterone routine comes to about $63 a month with no membership on top.3 If a low monthly number is what matters most to you, Alloy’s pill route is a strong option.

Alloy also lists many hormone forms, serves all 50 states and DC, and offers unlimited messaging.345

Want to use insurance instead? Neither Alloy nor Stay Prime bills insurance. Midi Health works with major insurers for its virtual visits, so it is worth a look if coverage matters to you.6

How Stay Prime is different

No prescription, no membership. If your clinician decides a prescription is not right for you, your membership never starts. Your $49 visit fee covers their time, and if you do join, it comes off your first month.

Every cost is shown before you pay. Her Balance is $89 a month. If a medication is prescribed, you see its price before you approve it.

Plain answers about hormones. The estradiol used in most hormone therapy is the same estrogen your ovaries make. Many forms, including pills and patches, are FDA-approved. If a medication is ever compounded, we tell you, and compounded medications are not FDA-approved.

Questions people ask

Is Stay Prime cheaper than Alloy?

Not always. For an estradiol pill with progesterone, Alloy’s listed medication prices add up to less per month than a Stay Prime membership. Stay Prime is built for people who want one monthly price for their care and no membership charge if a prescription is not right for them. Compare the table above with your own plan.

What happens to my first visit fee?

It pays for your clinician’s review. If you join Her Balance, the full visit fee comes off your first month. If your clinician decides a prescription is not right for you, your membership never starts.

Will I definitely get a prescription?

No. Prescriptions are issued only if a licensed clinician determines they are appropriate for you. It is not right for everyone, and your clinician will tell you if it is not right for you.

Can I use insurance?

We are cash-pay, so no insurance is needed. You may be able to pay with an HSA or FSA card, so check with your plan. Want to submit to your insurer yourself? We will give you an itemized receipt.

See if Her Balance fits you.

Start with a short questionnaire. A licensed clinician reviews it, and prescriptions are issued only if the clinician determines it is appropriate.

Sources

Competitor prices checked November 2026; they may have changed. Check each company’s own site before you decide.

  1. Alloy, doctor consultation: https://myalloy.com/drconsult
  2. Alloy, solutions and pricing: https://www.myalloy.com/solutions
  3. Alloy, hormone replacement therapy: https://www.myalloy.com/hrt
  4. Alloy, FAQ: https://www.myalloy.com/faq
  5. Alloy, homepage: https://www.myalloy.com/
  6. Midi Health, pricing and insurance: https://www.joinmidi.com/pricing-insurance

Alloy and Midi Health are trademarks of their owners. Stay Prime Health is not affiliated with or endorsed by either company.

More comparisons: Stay Prime vs Evernow, Stay Prime vs Hers, Stay Prime vs Hims.